Skip to main content
Which One?

Best T-shirt Quilt Companies Compared

Same idea. Very different results.

Some companies make quilts.

Some make blankets.

Some keep every block the same size.

Others offer more design flexibility.

Compare the major differences before you send your T-shirts anywhere.

How to Use This Comparison

Style Matters

Questions to Ask Quilt Maker

Company Details

 

runDisney T-shirt Quilt by Too Cool T-shirt Quilts

Quick Comparison of T-shirt Quilt Companies

*Prices and offerings can change. Check each company’s website before ordering.

Jump to Company Details

 

Founded

Makes Quilts, Blankets or Both

Main Style

Starting Price Range

Too Cool T-shirt Quilts (that's us!)

1992

Quilts

Puzzle style

$446 to $1,198

Campus Quilts

2000

Quilts and Blankets

Traditional style, with or without sashing

$69 to $949

Quilt My Shirts

2001

Quilts

Traditional style, with or without sashing

$232 to $900

Keepsake T-shirt Quilts

1998

Quilts and blankets

Traditional style, with or without sashing

$69 to $429

T-shirt Quilt Cafe

2007

Blankets

Traditional without sashing

$159 to $610

Memory Stitch

Unknown

Quilts and blankets

Traditional without sashing

$110 to $800

Project Repat

2012

Blankets

Traditional without sashing

$45 to $289

American Quilt Company

Unknown

Blankets

Traditional without sashing

$120 to $450

How to Use This Comparison

The best T-shirt quilt company for you depends on what you want made.

A lower priced blanket may be the right choice if you want something simple and casual. A true quilt may be a better choice if you want more structure, longer life, quilting, binding, and a finished quilt feel.

The important thing is to know what you are buying before you ship your T-shirts.

↑ Back to the Top

Comparing a Too Cool T-shirt Quilt runDisney T-shirt quilt
to a Project Repat runDisney blanket.

Comparison

Quilt vs. Blanket

This is the most important thing to understand!

One of the biggest differences between companies is whether they make a quilt or a blanket.

A T-shirt quilt and a T-shirt blanket are not the same thing.

They may both use T-shirts, but the construction, feel, price, and longevity can be very different.

A T-shirt quilt has three layers: the T-shirts on top, batting in the middle, and backing fabric on the bottom. A T-shirt blanket usually has just two layers: T-shirts on the front and fleece, flannel, or another fabric on the back. This is one of the biggest construction differences.

A quilt is quilted. The stitching holds all three layers together so they don’t shift, stretch, or pull apart. A blanket is not quilted. The front and back can move separately. A blanket is faster and cheaper to make.

The finishes are different too. Blankets often have a quick pillowcase-style finish with no binding. A quilt has a bound edge. Binding takes more time and skill, but it looks better, feels better, and lasts longer.

↑ Back to the Top

fleece on back of a blanket
Comparison

Style Matters

T-shirt quilts are made in different styles.

The style affects how the finished quilt looks, how your shirts are used, and how much design flexibility you have.

 

 

Comparison

Quality of Materials Used

Backing

The backing is the fabric on the back of the quilt. It matters because it affects how the quilting looks, how the quilt feels, and how well the quilt holds up over time. There are a lot of backing fabrics a quilt maker can choose from, but not all backing fabrics are equal. Too Cool T-shirt Quilts uses high-quality 100% cotton quilting fabric, which wears well and works well in a quilt.

Batting

The batting is the layer in the middle of the quilt. You don’t see it, but you will feel it. Batting affects the thickness, softness, warmth, weight, and longevity of the quilt. The wrong batting can make a quilt too heavy, too stiff, too thin, or lumpy. The right batting helps the finished quilt feel like a real quilt and helps it hold up to use.

↑ Back to the Top

Backing and binding purple black

Which T-shirt Quilt Company Is Best?

There is no single best company for every customer.

The best choice depends on what you want:

What You Want

What to Look For

Lowest price

A T-shirt blanket company

A true quilt

A company that clearly makes quilts, not only blankets

T-shirts in a traditional grid

Traditional style with same size blocks

More design flexibility

Puzzle style or variable layout

A stained-glass look

Stained-glass puzzle style

Longest company history

Compare founding years

Larger sizes

Check size options before ordering

Questions to Ask Before You Choose a Company

Before you send your T-shirts anywhere, ask these questions:

  • Are they making a quilt or a blanket?
  • What style will the finished piece be?
  • Are all shirts cut the same size?
  • Can different size graphics be used well?
  • What sizes are available?
  • What is included in the price?
  • Is quilting included?
  • Is binding included?
  • What backing options are available?
  • How long has the company been making T-shirt quilts?

These questions help you compare the real product, not just the price.

↑ Back to the Top

Sewers line up

Company Details

Bottom Line

A T-shirt quilt is not something you order every day. Most people only do this once or twice, and the T-shirts usually matter.

That is why comparison shopping is worth the time.

Look beyond the price. Look at the construction, style, size options, and the finished look of each company’s work. Once you know the difference between a quilt and a blanket, and once you understand the different styles, the right choice becomes much clearer.

↑ Back to the Top

March 26 - 9-1

FAQs

Why do T-shirt quilt prices vary so much?

Are cheaper T-shirt quilts/blankets worth it?

What style of T-shirt quilt looks best?

Should I choose a company that makes quilts or blankets?

What our customers are saying

“Heading off to college, I wanted something to remember all of the good times Ive had before left home.

Too Cool T-shirt Quilts allowed me to recycle some of the old T-shirts I had outgrown into something new that I can appreciate and enjoy for years to come.”

Jacks quilt with border with flannel in border 3

Best present I've ever received!

During our 52 years of marriage, I’ve cuddled up to 'Bear' in each of these shirts.  Now this quilt is the closest thing I have to being with him again!

Bear T-shirt Quilt by Too Cool T-shirt Quilts